LUTON FANS

“Taking Chong and McGuinness is surely the biggest favour any club has ever done us. Are they owned by a Luton fan?”

“Spot on.
They look like a club on the way down.”

“Not bothered about mcguiness leaving personally.

3 games aside, he was bang average and switched-off far too often.”

“Turning circle of a dead elephant”

“90% of our fans have wanted him gone since the minute we signed him.”

“was never good enough and other defenders and goal keepers were not confident along side him”

“please watch back his performances for us – always in the wrong place, on the wrong foot and slow as arseholes – he can head the ball by virtue of being very tall.”

“Can head the ball. Thats it”

“was never worth what we paid and ultimately wasn’t a huge success.”

“Never been fully convinced. Had as many bad games as good ones for us but has potential.”

“Will head everything away but not the quickest”

“Had so much potential. I get he was marmite with the fanbase but I think the guy was really underrated”

“Don’t understand the Mcguinness hate. Outstanding for us last season after Edwards went. I’ll never forget that performance against Derby. Obviously been ill before season began and getting back to full fitness. So many just written him off”

“Had the makings of a centre-back I’d hoped would be here for years to come.
I’m sure he’ll do well there”

“towards the end of last season McGuinness was one of our best players. Coming back from illness and a very good Championship player.”

“He was our most consistent player for most of last season.
Quite often let down by those around him, having to come off his own player to cover.”

“He was good from around March last year. Desperately needs pace alongside him. Brave with blocks, not too comfortable with ball at feet and can have the odd mistake but really picked up in our good run late last year and was an aerial colossus at times.”

“This is our biggest loss this season. I was hoping McGuinness would give us a year.”

“he’s a good player.”

CARDIFF FANS

” He is error prone. Solid enough with the physical side but his pace and his ability on the ball is poor. A danger from set pieces. Under the right manager he could be special. We ripped Luton off with how much we charged them for him.”

“Best thing Mick McCarthy ever did for Cardiff City was sign Mark McGuiness”

“the only decent thing MM did was to give us Mark McGuinness”

“One great thing big Mick did was bringing in Mark McGuinness”

“Top centre half, very solid and good in the air.”

“Mark is a class act, on and off the pitch…”

“without a doubt he’s a class act”

“Really liked Mcguinness’ positioning and composure on/off the ball”

“One of the most underrated defenders in the league, prem bound for sure”

“he’s good in both boxes, and has all the tools to make an EPL defender.”

“I wouldn’t be surprised at all if he made it in The Prem”

“Top Championship centre half”

“He’s committed, no doubt, but he just doesn’t have the skill-set to be considered a Premier League player.”

“McGuinness is a championship standard player.”

“I always liked his attitude but never rated him as highly as other CBs we’ve had over the years. Too many simple mistakes for me. Not sure where the “good distribution” praise comes from because my (albeit foggy) memory has him passing it to the other team more than a 5 million pound striker should.”

WEDNESDAY FANS

“Mark McGuinness to the pigs . What did we do in our past lives?”

“Loved McGuinness when he played for us. Proper defender. Great signing for them.
Definitely need to get the derby game abandoned! 
They could batter us by 5 or 6 goals. Embarrassing. What a shambles of a club we are.”

“He was outstanding for us. Stunned he’s not in the Premier League”

“we were in L1 at the time but he was absolutely class”

“Consistently 8+ performances for us”

“Best CB Ive seen at Hillsborough for many a year, Storey was good but had no pace and was prone to the occasional lapse, this lads just quality and hes switched on from the 1st whistle, a proper warrior”

“Incredible loan signing. Destined for the top level. “

“Absolutely immense and left it all out there . Premier League bound. Super defender.”

“Superb defender and will easy play at a premier league club one day”

“Should be playing in the premier league with us!”

“The lad put his body in front of everything. What a superstar.”

“McGuinness is magnificent in the air”

“McGuinness was good here, but his whole 4-5 year career has been spent playing in L1 or the bottom end of the Championship. Think Cardiff managed one midtable finish which is the highest he’s ever finished. He looked poor for Luton last season.

Not many players who’ve had two multi million pound transfers (Luton paid £10m, sure they’ll have paid less though) can match that. “

“Dish is miles better  and max”

“Jarvis thornton i plead with you to end mark mcguinness career on the 23rd of november”